Dedicated locality research platform
Enter your email address and you will receive
a link to reset your password
The historic Mehta Mahal, a 56-year-old commercial building nestled on Mathew Road, has once again become the epicentre of legal turmoil as the Bombay High Court prepares to examine the civic guidelines governing unsafe structures. This iconic property, known for its disputed history, has drawn significant attention due to a 2021 report by an expert panel commissioned by the BMC, evaluating its structural stability.
The ongoing legal battle surrounding Mehta Mahal, famously dubbed one of the most contentious properties in South Mumbai by the Bombay High Court, now carries immense implications for the enforceability of local body guidelines in favour of private individuals.
The BMC, relying on recommendations from its technical advisory committee (TAC), had initially granted the Mehta Mahal Commercial Cooperative Premises Society Ltd permission to undertake immediate repairs on the building. In contrast, Drishti Hospitality Company Pvt Ltd, one of the property's owners, has vehemently contested this approach, rechristening the premises as 'Drishti House.' They cited a report from IIT-Bombay, categorizing the building as 'dangerous' and advocating for its demolition. Both the society and Drishti Hospitality have approached the Bombay High Court, seeking clarity on whether the 13-floor structure can be rehabilitated or must be razed to the ground.
Beyond the immediate dispute over Mehta Mahal, the High Court will deliberate on a broader issue—the viability of civic policies for handling unsafe buildings. The bench, comprising Justices Gautam Patel and Neela Gokhale, has expressed its intention to scrutinize the legal status of guidelines adopted by local authorities following court interim orders. Specifically, the court will assess whether such guidelines, albeit advisory in nature, can confer enforceable rights upon private individuals. This pivotal question could have far-reaching implications for future property disputes and civic policies.
The legal saga surrounding Mehta Mahal is further complicated by the existence of seven different proceedings, a testament to its storied past as a charitable trust-owned property. Drishti Hospitality, represented by senior counsel Sharan Jagtiani and advocate Manoj Agiwal, has invoked the IIT-Bombay report to request that the society produce a counter structural assessment, potentially leading to another referral to the TAC for evaluation.
In response, the society, represented by counsel Karl Tamboly and advocate Samit Shukla, has emphasized that they secured permissions for repairs based on the 2021 TAC report, with substantial progress already made (70% completion). The permission, valid until July 8, 2024, remains unchallenged directly, notwithstanding Drishti Hospitality's claims regarding the extent of repairs accomplished.
The Bombay High Court, taking all arguments into account, expressed reservations about disrupting the ongoing repairs, noting that a repair permission sanctioned by the MCGM based on the TAC report should not be hastily overridden by introducing another report and seeking a fresh TAC referral. With repairs still underway, the Court scheduled the next hearing for November 2, 2023.
The fate of Mehta Mahal and the precedent set regarding enforceability of civic guidelines hang in the balance as the legal battle unfolds within the hallowed halls of the Bombay High Court.
Propscience is India’s dedicated property news portal. We cover the latest events, news, trends, deals, new launches and more.
All our services and tools are completely free of cost and available 24X7!
We use cookies to give you the best possible service while using our website, please click accept and carry on browsing if you're happy with this. For more information see our Privacy Policy.
Okay, Got it!This disclaimer ("Disclaimer") is applicable to the entire Site. Upon entering the Site it is recommended that you immediately read the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy listed therein. Your continued usage of this Site will indicate your unconditional acceptance of the said Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. You hereby agree that Propscience reserves the right to modify at any time, the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy governing this Site without prior notification. Your usage of the Site implies that you will be bound by any such modification. You agree and acknowledge that it is your responsibility to periodically visit the Site and stay updated with the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy of the Website.
The information contained in this Site has been provided by Propscience for information purposes only. This information does not constitute legal, professional or commercial advice. Communication, content and material within the Site may include photographs and conceptual representations of projects under development. All computer-generated images shown on the Site are only indicative of actual designs and are sourced from third party sites.
The information on this Site may contain certain technical inaccuracies and typographical errors. Any errors or omissions brought to the attention of Propscience will be corrected as soon as possible. The content of this Site is being constantly modified to meet the terms, stipulations and recommendations of the Real Estate Regulation Act, 2016 ("RERA") and rules made thereunder and may vary from the content available as of date. All content may be updated from time to time and may at times be out of date. Propscience accepts no responsibility for keeping the information in this website up to date or any liability whatsoever for any failure to do so.
While every care has been taken to ensure that the content is useful, reliable and accurate, all content and information on the Site is provided on an "as is" and "as available" basis. Propscience does not accept any responsibility or liability with regard to the content, accuracy, legality and reliability of the information provided herein, or, for any loss or damage caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with reliance on the use of such information. No information given under this Site creates a warranty or expands the scope of any warranty that cannot be disclaimed under applicable law.
This Site provides links to other websites owned by third parties. Any reference or mention to third party websites, projects or services is for purely informational purposes only. This information does not constitute either an endorsement or a recommendation. Propscience accepts no responsibility for the content, reliability and information provided on these third-party websites. Propscience will not be held liable for any personal information of data collected by these third parties or for any virus or destructive properties that may be present on these third-party sites.
Your use of the Site is solely at your own risk. You agree and acknowledge that you are solely responsible for any action you take based upon this content and that Propscience is not liable for the same. All details regarding a project/property provided on this Site are updated on the basis of information available from the respective developers/owners/promoters. All such information will not be construed as an advertisement. To find out more about a project / development, please register/contact us to visit the site you are interested in. All decisions taken by you in this regard will be taken independently and Propscience will not be liable for any such loss in connection with the same. This Site is for guidance only. Your use of this Site - including any suggestions set out in the Site and or any use of the resources available on this Site, do not create any professional - client relationship between you and Propscience. Propscience cannot accept you as a client until certain formalities and requirements are met.
We use cookies to give you the best possible service while using our website, please accept it and continue browsing if you're happy with this. For more information see our Privacy Policy